Discover The Top 50 Car Insurance Companies That Everyone Is Talking About!​

Best Buy Auto Insurance

Share This Post

List of Topics

The top auto insurance provider is now USAA, with American Family coming in at number two. At No. 3, State Farm is followed by a tie between Geico and Nationwide.

According to price based on driving history, age, credit history, coverage level, and performance in terms of customer service, claims management, and customer loyalty, we examined over 30 vehicle insurance providers.

You Won't Believe Which Car Insurance Companies Made It to the Top!

The top 50 Car insurance Companies are listed below, along with a brief description of each business and The Average Annual Rates: 

1. **USAA – $1,022**: USAA is renowned for its exceptional service, primarily serving military members and their families. They offer competitive rates and a wide range of coverage options.

2. **American Family – $1,383**: American Family is known for its commitment to customer satisfaction. They provide affordable rates and comprehensive coverage, making them a solid choice.

3. **State Farm – $1,279**: State Farm is one of the largest insurers in the U.S. They offer a variety of insurance products, including car insurance, with a strong network of agents.

4. **Geico – $1,250**: Geico is famous for its affordability and witty advertising. They provide straightforward online quotes and 24/7 customer service.

5. **Nationwide – $1,473**: Nationwide offers customizable policies and discounts. They have a strong reputation for customer care.

6. **Farmers – $2,078**: Farmers provides a wide range of coverage options. They are known for their personalized service but may be on the higher end in terms of rates.

7. **Travelers – $1,355**: Travelers offers competitive rates and various discounts. They have a strong network of agents and a solid reputation.

8. **Allstate – $2,135**: Allstate is a well-known insurer with various coverage options. They offer tools like Drivewise to help you save on premiums.

9. **AAA – $1,958**: AAA is renowned for its roadside assistance but also provides car insurance. They offer discounts to members.

10. **Progressive – $1,540**: Progressive is known for its innovative approach to car insurance. They offer Snapshot, a program that tracks your driving habits to determine rates.

11. **Liberty Mutual – $1,542**: Liberty Mutual provides a variety of coverage options. They are known for their customizable policies and multi-policy discounts.

12. **MetLife – $1,973**: MetLife offers car insurance with additional benefits like identity theft protection. They have a strong financial rating.

13. **Esurance – $1,181**: Esurance is an online-focused insurer, providing quick and convenient quotes. They offer a range of coverage options.

14. **The Hartford – $1,578**: The Hartford specializes in coverage for older drivers. They offer benefits like RecoverCare to help with daily tasks after an accident.

15. **Safeco – $1,448**: Safeco offers affordable coverage and a range of discounts. They are known for their claims service.

16. **21st Century – $1,345**: 21st Century offers budget-friendly coverage. They provide online quotes and 24/7 customer service.

17. **Mercury – $1,493**: Mercury is known for its low rates and optional coverages. They have a strong presence in California.

18. **Amica Mutual – $1,331**: Amica Mutual consistently receives high customer satisfaction ratings. They offer a range of coverage options.

19. **Erie – $1,052**: Erie provides affordable rates and excellent customer service. They have a strong presence in the Midwest.

20. **Kemper – $1,548**: Kemper offers non-standard auto insurance for high-risk drivers. They cater to drivers who may have difficulty getting coverage elsewhere.

21. **The General – $2,112**: The General specializes in high-risk auto insurance. They provide coverage for drivers with a challenging history.

22. **American National – $1,684**: American National offers a range of coverage options and discounts. They have a strong financial rating.

23. **Bristol West – $1,870**: Bristol West is a subsidiary of Farmers Insurance Group. They offer non-standard auto insurance for high-risk drivers.

24. **National General – $1,590**: National General provides coverage for a range of drivers, including those with accidents or violations on their record.

25. **Shelter – $1,250**: Shelter offers competitive rates and various coverage options. They are known for their commitment to community involvement.

26. **Elephant – $1,291**: Elephant Insurance offers online quotes and customizable policies. They aim to make insurance straightforward.

27. **Hanover – $1,558**: Hanover Insurance focuses on personalized service. They offer a range of coverage options for individuals and businesses.

28. **Horace Mann – $1,275**: Horace Mann specializes in coverage for educators. They offer discounts to teachers and school employees.

29. **Mendota – $1,715**: Mendota Insurance provides non-standard auto insurance for high-risk drivers. They aim to provide accessible coverage.

30. **Direct Auto – $2,006**: Direct Auto focuses on non-standard auto insurance. They cater to drivers who may have difficulty getting coverage elsewhere.

31. **Safe Auto – $1,720**: Safe Auto offers affordable rates for high-risk drivers. They provide the necessary coverage to meet legal requirements.

32. **Electric Insurance – $1,180**: Electric Insurance offers auto insurance with additional benefits like identity theft protection.

33. **Acceptance – $2,065**: Acceptance Insurance provides non-standard auto insurance for high-risk drivers. They aim to make coverage accessible.

34. **Kemper Specialty – $1,902**: Kemper Specialty offers non-standard auto insurance for high-risk drivers. They provide coverage to those who may have difficulty getting insured elsewhere.

35. **Dairyland – $1,771**: Dairyland specializes in non-standard auto insurance. They cater to high-risk drivers and those with challenging driving histories.

36. **Hallmark – $2,208**: Hallmark Insurance focuses on non-standard auto insurance for high-risk drivers. They provide coverage for those who may have difficulty getting insured elsewhere.

37. **GAINSCO – $2,274**: GAINSCO specializes in non-standard auto insurance, particularly for high-risk drivers. They provide accessible coverage options.

38. **Alfa – $1,523**: Alfa Insurance offers a range of coverage options and discounts. They are known for their commitment to customer satisfaction.

39. **Cure – $1,215**: Cure Auto Insurance provides coverage for New Jersey and Pennsylvania residents. They offer competitive rates and focus on safe driving.

40. **Wawanesa – $1,063**: Wawanesa Insurance provides coverage primarily in California and Oregon. They are known for their affordability and customer service.

41. **Concord Group – $1,123**: The Concord Group offers insurance coverage in the New England region. They provide a range of coverage options for individuals and businesses.

42. **NJM – $1,215**: NJM Insurance Group serves policyholders in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. They are known for their competitive rates and excellent customer service.

43. **Grange – $1,425**: Grange Insurance offers coverage options in several states. They provide a variety of policies for individuals and businesses.

44. **American Independent – $2,318**: American Independent Insurance specializes in non-standard auto insurance for high-risk drivers. They aim to provide accessible coverage.

45. **Acuity – $1,388**: Acuity Insurance offers a range of coverage options for individuals and businesses. They are known for their strong financial rating.

46. **Foremost – $2,587**: Foremost Insurance focuses on specialty insurance, including coverage for high-risk drivers and unique


47. **AARP – $1,250**: AARP offers car insurance to its members. They provide competitive rates and additional benefits.

48. **Chubb – $1,274**: Chubb Insurance offers coverage options for high-value vehicles and high-net-worth individuals. They are known for their tailored policies.

49. **Pure – $1,201**: Pure Insurance specializes in high-value auto coverage. They cater to individuals with luxury or high-end vehicles.

50. **National Interstate – $1,412**: National Interstate Insurance focuses on specialty insurance, including commercial auto coverage.

    Please note that these explanations provide a general overview of each company’s offerings and reputation. It’s advisable to research further and obtain quotes to determine the best fit for your specific insurance needs.

You won't believe which car insurance companies made the top 10!

According to our research, USAA is the best insurance provider, but it’s not available to the general public. American Family, ranked No. 2, may be the finest auto insurance provider for many motorists.


Wow, you won’t believe it! This amazing service is available not just in one or two states, but in all 50 states and Washington, D.C.! And that’s not all – it has been rated as the absolute best for customer service! How do we know? Well, they conducted a policyholder survey and guess what? They came out on top! Talk about impressive!


USAA, the No. 1 insurer in our Best Car Insurance Companies of 2023 rating, has got everyone buzzing! Their policies cater exclusively to members of the military, veterans, and their families. And boy, did they sweep the competition! They clinched the top spot in so many subcategories it’s mind-blowing:

 Customer Service? Check. Most Likely to be Recommended? Check. Most Likely to Be Renewed? Double check! Sure, they came in second for Claims Handling and tied with American Family for Customer Loyalty, but that’s just a minor setback.

 Plus, when it comes to offering affordable coverage, USAA reigns supreme as the Best Cheap Car Insurance Company. Now, keep in mind that USAA car insurance is limited to military folks, so if you’re not part of that community, don’t fret! There are plenty of other insurers out there itching to win your heart. But seriously, USAA deserves a standing ovation for their stellar performance!

Contact Info

USAA Banking Routing Number


USAA Main Mailing Address

9800 Fredericksburg Rd.
San Antonio, TX 78288


American Family

Car Insurance


We are thrilled to announce that we have claimed the top spot in our customer survey analysis for our exceptional claims handling! Not only that, but we also received outstanding ratings for our customer service in the same survey. We couldn’t be more excited about these achievements and are grateful to our customers for their trust and satisfaction.


Operates only in 19 states.

Many rivals present more affordable prices.

With a score of 4.3 out of 5, American Family came in second in our overall ranking of the best auto insurers and ranked high in the most of the subcategories we looked at. The business ranks first in both Customer Loyalty and Claims Handling, where it is tied for first place. American Family came in second or third in every other subcategory. The company placed fifth overall in our ranking of Cheap Car Insurance Companies and is directly in the middle of insurers in terms of pricing.

Contact Info :

Call  anytime:  1-800-692-6326 . 24/7

Customer Service/Sales:  Phone: 1-888-239-9953


Fax: 1-920-330-5607.

State Farm


We are absolutely thrilled to announce that our customer service has received incredibly high ratings from our current policyholders! Not only that, but our premiums are often priced below the national average. Isn’t that exciting?


Get ready to be blown away by State Farm! This incredible insurance company, rated a whopping 4.2 out of 5, has secured the number 3 spot in our ranking. And let me tell you, they truly deserve it! State Farm excelled in every single subcategory we assessed, making them an all-around superstar.

Not only did they claim the prestigious title of being the second-best car insurance company for seniors, but they also tied with American Family for outstanding customer service at number 2. And that’s not all – State Farm is part of a fierce four-way tie for third place in the Claims Handling subcategory. They truly know how to handle your needs!

But hold on, it gets even better! State Farm offers some of the most affordable rates out there. In fact, their rates are the third-lowest overall. They also performed exceptionally well in various rate-specific categories such as insurance costs for teen drivers and seniors. If you’ve got a need for speed and have had a speeding ticket or accident, look no further than State Farm – they’re one of the cheapest options around. And guess what? They’re also the most affordable choice after a DUI.

State Farm is revolutionizing the insurance game with their unbeatable policies and top-notch services. Don’t miss out on this incredible opportunity to join their satisfied customer base. Get yourself covered with State Farm today!

Contact Info :

Auto/Home/Property claims
Mailing address
State Farm Insurance Companies
Insurance Support Center – East
P.O. Box 588002
North Metro, GA 30029


Car Insurance


offers some of the lowest average annual rates among the other businesses in our rating

According to policyholder comments, does well in the areas of claims management, customer loyalty, and customer service.


In our investigation, drivers with DUIs typically had higher rates than the bulk of suppliers.

In our ranking of the Best Auto Insurance Companies of 2023, Geico and Nationwide are tied for fourth place with a score of 4.1. The company dropped one position from the previous year, when it tied for third place with another company. Every segment in our ranking saw Geico place in the top half, with top-5 rankings for Customer Service, Claims Handling, and Customer Loyalty.

Additionally, it is among the list’s least expensive auto insurance providers. In our ranking of Cheap Car Insurance Companies, Geico came in second place overall, trailing only USAA. Geico offers competitive prices in a variety of areas, including inexpensive premiums for drivers wanting minimum coverage and teen drivers.

Contact Info :

Customer service
1 (800) 207-7847

Email To:

Customer Service: (866) 760-4166

Classic Car Insurance:(866) 344-2527


Car Insurance


According to a poll of policyholders, customer service and claims management received above-average ratings.

rates that are affordable for drivers with bad credit.


Average minimum coverage costs are higher than those charged by competitors.

Drivers with DUIs pay greater premiums than the national average.

With a general score of 4.1, Nationwide is equal with Geico for fourth place in our ranking. The business is ranked No. 4 in the subcategory of customer service, No. 3 in the subcategory of claims handling, and No. 6 in the subcategory of customer loyalty. In the Most Likely to be Recommended and Most Likely to be Renewed categories, it came in the top five.

Nationwide came in at No. 6 overall in our ranking of the best cheap auto insurance providers, right in the middle.

Contact Info :

9 a.m. – 8 p.m. ET weekdays

8 a.m. – 9 p.m. ET weekdays
9 a.m. – 7 p.m. ET Sat/Sun

File a claim


Car Insurance


Customer service receives great reviews from current policyholders.

The majority of surveyed clients are content with how claims are resolved.


According to our data, most other insurers’ average yearly premiums are greater.

Together with Travelers, Allstate, and AAA, Farmers is ranked No. 6 overall among the Best Car Insurance Companies of 2023. The organization is ranked No. 3 in claims handling, No. 4 in our customer service area, and No. 6 in our customer loyalty category. In the subcategory “Most Likely to be Renewed,” farmers came in bottom.

In our survey, Farmers frequently offers some of the highest rates on average, and in our most recent ranking of affordable auto insurance providers, they came in ninth place.

Contact Info :

9 a.m. – 8 p.m. ET weekdays

8 a.m. – 9 p.m. ET weekdays
9 a.m. – 7 p.m. ET Sat/Sun

File a claim


Car Insurance


lower than the national average, on an annual basis


Policyholders polled give it low grades for processing claims

In our ranking, Travelers remains in the same spot it held the year before at No. 6, where it is tied with four other insurers. In our ranking, Travelers ranks No. 4 in Customer Service, which is the greatest position it can get in any of the subcategories. It came in lowest in the Most Likely to be Recommended category, sixth in customer loyalty, and seventh in claims handling.

With premiums below the national average in all of the categories we looked at, including those for teen drivers, young adults, and elderly drivers, as well as the price of coverage after a ticket or DUI, Travelers has affordable overall rates.

Contact Info :

Get a Quote
1.866.715.1677  Quote Online

Billing and Policy Service Questions 1.800.842.5075

Report a Claim 1.800.252.4633


Car Insurance


According to client comments, opening a new policy is simple.


Rates are substantially higher than the norm for the country.

The highest position Allstate held in any of our subcategories was sixth in Customer Loyalty and Most Likely to be Recommended. Additionally, it was ranked No. 6 overall among the Best Automobile Insurance Providers in 2023. It came in seventh or lower in the subcategories of Customer Service, Claims Handling, and Most Likely to be Renewed.

The firm is among the most expensive in our ranking, with premiums that are more expensive than the national average in every pricing category we looked at, including rates for juvenile and senior drivers, prices after a speeding citation, and rates after an accident. It was ranked No. 10 in our ranking of affordable auto insurance providers.

Contact Info :

Customer service: 800-726-6033.

Business Insurance: call 800-659-3144.

Address: 3100 Sanders Road
Northbrook, IL 60062


Car Insurance


Provides numerous discounts to increase your savings. offers supplemental protection, such as gap insurance.



Overall, rates are higher than the average for the country.

In two of our ranking’s subcategories, Customer Service and Claims Handling, AAA received a position of No. 10. However, the business shares the No. 5 slot in Most Likely to Be Renewed and the No. 4 spot in Customer Loyalty. It is ranked No. 6 in terms of being Most Likely to be Recommend.

In our ranking of the Best Car Insurance Companies of 2023, AAA is ranked as the No. 6 company overall (in a tie with four other companies).

In a number of categories, sample rates for AAA auto insurance were higher than the US average.

Contact Info :

Report a claim 24/7: 1-800-67-CLAIM (1-800-672-5246)

Contact AAA ; Or call: 800.564.6222


Car Insurance


Annual rates for drivers with bad credit or DUI that are lower than average. provides a good assortment of special offers


Young drivers, with the second-highest average rates.

based on comments from policyholders, ranks last for customer loyalty.

In our ranking of the top auto insurance providers, Progressive is ranked No. 10. It came in at No. 10 in the Customer Loyalty subcategory. It did slightly better in other classifications, although it was still rated in the bottom half of each. Progressive ranks eighth for customer service, seventh for claims handling, and ninth for most likely to be recommended in our analysis.

Additionally, our research revealed that Progressive’s rates in a number of areas are higher than the US average.

Contact Info :

Commercial Customer Service


General Customer Service


Corporate headquarters

The Progressive Corporation 6300 Wilson Mills Rd. Mayfield Village, Ohio 44143.

What Is the Best Car Insurance Company?

Don’t waste your time with average car insurers, go for the best!

 If you’re looking for the best car insurance company, our analysis points to USAA as the top choice. However, keep in mind that USAA is only available to certain individuals. For those who don’t qualify for USAA, American Family comes in at a close second and may be the best option for many drivers. State Farm, Geico, and Nationwide also rank highly in our ratings. 

Ultimately, the best car insurance company for you depends on various factors such as your age, location, driving record, and personal preferences. These preferences could include excellent customer service, a reputable name, or efficient claims handling. To help determine which company aligns with your needs, we conducted a survey of current policyholders from each of our top-rated car insurance companies. Below, you’ll find their ratings in several categories focused on customer service.

State Farm, USAA, and American Family provide the best customer service.

  When it comes to customer service, USAA takes the lead as the top-ranked company in the subcategory. American Family and State Farm share the second spot, both providing commendable service. Our survey reveals that a significant 73% of USAA customers who have not filed a claim are completely satisfied with the customer service they receive. However, this number drops to 53% among customers who have filed a claim. 

It’s important to note that USAA car insurance policies are exclusively available to members of the military community and their families, so it may be wise for most customers to explore other insurers in our rating.

 Meanwhile, over 65% of American Family customers who haven’t filed a claim express complete satisfaction with their customer service experience. The number slightly decreases to just under 58% among policyholders who have filed a claim. State Farm customers also report similar levels of satisfaction, with approximately 60% and 54% respectively for those who haven’t and have filed a claim. Finally, Nationwide, Geico, Travelers, and Farmers all tie at No. 4 in this subcategory of customer service quality.

Best at handling claims: American Family

Welcome to our guide on the top performers in the Claims Handling subcategory! American Family has claimed the number one spot with an impressive score of 4.3, narrowly surpassing USAA, which earned a commendable score of 4.2. Our survey results reveal that a remarkable 61% of American Family policyholders are completely satisfied with the ease of filing a claim, while 56% express complete satisfaction with how their claims were resolved.

 Additionally, just under 52% of American Family customers expressed complete satisfaction regarding the status updates they received while their claim was being processed. Following closely behind American Family and USAA is a four-way tie for third place between State Farm, Farmers, Geico, and Nationwide. Progressive, Travelers, and Allstate share seventh place, while AAA secures the tenth position.

Most Likely To Be Recommend: American Family and USAA

If you’re in search of a highly recommended insurer for your car, look no further than USAA. They have claimed the top spot in the Most Likely to be Recommended subcategory, surpassing American Family at number two. Our survey has revealed that an impressive 63% of USAA policyholders who haven’t filed a claim are extremely likely to suggest this company to others seeking car insurance. However, this percentage drops slightly to around 59% among USAA customers who have filed a claim. It’s worth noting that USAA exclusively caters to members of the military community, so if you don’t fall into this category, you may need to explore other insurance options.

American Family also garners positive recommendations from its policyholders. Just over 40% of American Family policyholders who haven’t filed a claim express a high likelihood of recommending the insurer to someone seeking coverage. Meanwhile, just over 62% of those who have filed a claim are very likely to offer their recommendation.

Additionally, State Farm, Nationwide, and Geico are other companies that receive commendations from their customers and are tied for third place in our rating within this subcategory.

USAA and American Family are the most likely to be renewed

If you’re wondering whether USAA policyholders are likely to renew their policies, our survey results show that over 69% of customers who haven’t filed a claim said they are very likely to do so. Even among policyholders who have filed a claim, the numbers remained steady with more than 66% describing themselves as very likely to renew. 

These impressive results have earned USAA the top spot in the Most Likely to be Renewed subcategory. American Family, coming in at No. 2, also performed well in our consumer survey. Approximately 65% of those who haven’t filed a claim expressed a high likelihood of renewing with American Family, and this number increased to over 68% among those who have filed a claim. Nationwide and State Farm share the No. 3 spot in this subcategory, while Geico ranks at No. 5.

USAA and American Family are the best in terms of customer loyalty

USAA and American Family are ranked as the top contenders in the Customer Loyalty subcategory, excelling in our survey by receiving high recommendations from their policyholders. In addition, USAA and American Family claimed the first and second positions in the Most Likely to be Renewed subcategory. Nationwide and State Farm both secured the third spot, while Geico was rated fifth.

USAA and American Family are the best in terms of customer loyalty

State-by-State Car Insurance Rates

New Hampshire$1,530.00
New Jersey$1,706.00
New Mexico$1,530.00
New York$1,808.00
North Carolina$1,165.00
North Dakota$1,300.00
Rhode Island$1,831.00
South Carolina$1,813.00
South Dakota$1,577.00
Washington, DC$1,727.00
West Virginia$1,532.00

*Rates are based on average sample quotes for male and female drivers ages 25, 35, and 60 who drive 12,000 miles per year, have medium coverage, good credit, and have a clean driving record.

Decoding Car Insurance: What You Need to Know

Are you currently on the lookout for car insurance and feeling overwhelmed by the multitude of choices available to you? It might seem like unraveling a mysterious code, but fear not! We’re here to assist you every step of the way. Together, we’ll explore the realm of car insurance and simplify it so effortlessly that even your neighbor’s grandma will grasp it with ease.

Collision Car Insurance: When Bumps Happen

Picture this: you’re peacefully driving along when, out of nowhere, disaster strikes! Whether it’s a run-in with another vehicle, an encounter with a lamppost, or even an unexpected encounter with a UFO (well, maybe not that last one), fear not! The trusty collision insurance is here to guide you through the chaos. This invaluable coverage steps in to shield your precious ride from damage caused by these unforeseen events. In fact, it might even go the extra mile and help repair your car if it flips over or if you find yourself entangled in a hit-and-run situation. Rest easy knowing that collision insurance has got your back when life takes an unexpected turn on the road.

Comprehensive Car Insurance: Shielding Against Life's Surprises

Life can throw some curveballs at your car—natural disasters, fires, thieves, or vandals wreaking havoc. That’s where comprehensive insurance steps in. It’s like a protective force field for your vehicle, defending it against everything but collisions. While the law might not demand it, having comprehensive coverage can be a real lifesaver when you’re staring at a hefty repair bill.

Full Coverage Car Insurance: The Whole Package

Picture this: what if car insurance offered a convenient full coverage option? Believe it or not, such a solution exists. This ingenious insurance combination seamlessly integrates liability, collision, and comprehensive coverage into a single, hassle-free package. But hold on, there’s even more to it! It goes above and beyond by including additional essentials mandated by your state, such as uninsured motorist coverage, personal injury protection, or medical payments. Consider it as the ultimate VIP experience for your beloved vehicle.

Gap Insurance: Bridging the Value Gap

If you’re leasing or financing your car, gap insurance is your safety net. Picture this: your car gets swiped or totaled, and you owe more on it than it’s worth. That’s where gap insurance shines. It bridges the gap between your car’s value and your outstanding loan balance, so you’re not left footing the bill.

Liability Car Insurance: Covering the Other Guy

If you ever find yourself in a situation where you need to drive someone else’s car or rent a vehicle, don’t worry! Non-owner car insurance is here to help. It offers essential liability coverage in case you happen to get into an accident while driving someone else’s vehicle. Additionally, it can be a lifesaver if you’ve lost your license but still require proof of insurance (known as an SR-22). So, rest easy knowing that non-owner car insurance has got you covered in these scenarios.

Uninsured Motorist Car Insurance: Guarding Against the Unprepared

Ideally, all drivers would possess insurance. However, the real world presents a different scenario. Uninsured motorist coverage comes to your aid when you find yourself in a predicament with a driver who lacks liability insurance or flees without disclosing their insurance information. Think of it as a safeguard for your insurance, guaranteeing that you won’t be left stranded and unsupported.

Are You Paying Too Much? Discover the Real Cost of Car Insurance!

1. USAA$85$1,022
2. American Family$115$1,383
3. State Farm$107$1,279
4. Geico$104$1,250
4. Nationwide$123$1,473
6. Farmers$173$2,078
6. Travelers$113$1,355
6. Allstate$178$2,135
6. AAA$163$1,958
10. Progressive$128$1,540

Demystifying Car Insurance Costs: What's in Your Premium?

Hello everyone! Ever ponder the reason behind the format of your auto insurance bill? You may compare it to attempting to decipher a coded communication. So, do not worry! We’re here to explain it in straightforward terms. So take a cup of coffee, settle in, and let’s explore the factors that influence the price of your auto insurance.

The first consideration is location.

You might be surprised to learn that your location has a big impact on the cost of your auto insurance. Your premium can be on the higher side if you live in a busy metropolis where there is a larger danger of accidents, theft, and vandalism. The calm suburbs, however, can result in a small discount. Therefore, your address does matter.

Your Age and Driving Experience: Are You an Expert?

Age and experience affect how much a car insurance policy will cost. Younger drivers typically pay higher premiums, especially those who have just graduated from driving school. However, as you accumulate years of safe driving, your costs may start to decline. It’s like getting your chef’s license in terms of insurance.

Is the gender issue still relevant?

Your gender used to have a significant impact on insurance rates. But circumstances are changing, and gender-based pricing is now outlawed in several states. However, certain insurers might still take it into account, so it’s important to watch out for when you compare quotes.

Make and model of Your Trusty Steed

Your car is more than simply a set of wheels; it also affects your car insurance. Your premium may be influenced by the brand and model. Luxury or high-performance automobiles may have greater prices because of the high cost of maintenance or replacement parts. On the other hand, a dependable family automobile can imply less expensive insurance.

Going Back in Time: Your Record

Your driving record functions as a time capsule for auto insurance. Accidents, fines, and other blemishes might linger for some time. The better your rates, the cleaner your record. It’s similar to submitting a flawless CV for your application for auto insurance.

Minimum or Maximum Coverage: A Conundrum?

It’s like choosing from a menu when selecting your coverage level. Do you choose the most basic level of coverage or the entire spread? Naturally, your premium will increase if you select additional coverage. However, it also entails extra security for when you need it. Finding that sweet spot is the key.

The Art of Comparison when Looking for Savings

The golden rule of auto insurance is to shop around. It’s similar to finding a fantastic deal on your preferred device, except much bigger. Different insurance companies provide various discounts and pricing. Therefore, comparing quotes from many insurers is the best approach to find a price that matches your budget and a policy that meets your demands.

How Much Is Enough? The Car Insurance Quantity Game

So, how much auto insurance is recommended? It’s similar to Goldilocks and her porridge in that it’s just right—not too hot, nor too cold. The baseline is established by state regulations, most of which demand a certain level of liability insurance. Even added benefits like uninsured motorist insurance or personal injury protection (PIP) are included in some states.

But that doesn’t tell the whole tale. Your lender or lessor will have the final word on the insurance you require if you’re financing or leasing your vehicle. So keep in mind to refer to your financing agreement—it serves as your guide to the appropriate coverage.

And if you’re looking for more advice on how to choose the best auto insurance, we’ve got you covered. Visit our page on “How Much Car Insurance Do I Need?” for more information. It is your dependable ally while playing the insurance quantity game.

Folks, there you have it! Demystifying your auto insurance premium. It’s just common sense; it’s not rocket science. So drive carefully, maintain coverage, and may your premiums always be reasonable!


In order to determine the top car insurance companies, we conducted a thorough evaluation of each company’s average rates for different types of drivers, the extent of coverage options available, customer complaints, and collision repair ratings provided by professionals in the auto body industry. Our assessment of auto insurance rates (which accounted for 50% of our overall evaluation) was based on data gathered from Quadrant Information Services. 

We examined the average rates offered by each company for various driver profiles, including those with a clean driving record, those who have been involved in accidents, those with speeding tickets or DUI offenses, individuals with poor credit history, drivers caught without insurance coverage, as well as scenarios involving the addition of teen drivers, senior drivers, and young drivers. 

Unless otherwise specified, our rates were based on a 40-year-old female driver operating a Toyota RAV4 and maintaining coverage limits of $100,000 for bodily injury per person, $300,000 for bodily injury per accident, and $100,000 for property damage (commonly referred to as 100 300 100). Additionally, uninsured motorist coverage at limits of 100 300 was taken into account alongside collision and comprehensive insurance policies that carried a deductible of $500.

Car insurance coverage options (25% of score):

Every auto insurance company offers the fundamental coverage options like liability insurance, collision and comprehensive coverage, and other common features. However, it’s equally crucial to have access to extra coverage options that offer enhanced protection or potential savings. Within this category, we applaud companies that provide accident forgiveness, new car replacement, vanishing deductibles, usage-based or pay-per-mile insurance, and SR-22s. These additional offerings can truly make a difference in your insurance experience and provide you with the peace of mind you deserve.

Complaints (20% of score):

We collected complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, which keeps track of complaints filed against insurance companies in each state. When it comes to auto insurance, most complaints revolve around claims and include issues like unfair settlements, delays, and rejections. On average, the industry receives a complaint ratio of 1.00. Therefore, companies with a ratio lower than 1.00 tend to have fewer customer complaints.

Based on our comprehensive ratings, the top car insurance companies in 2023 include USAA, American Family, State Farm, Geico, Nationwide, Farmers, Travelers, Allstate, AAA, and Progressive. These rankings are determined through a combination of survey responses from 9,500 consumers and other reliable sources.

Our research indicates that in 2023, USAA and American Family stand out as the best car insurance companies. They received high overall scores of 4.4 and 4.3, respectively, in our evaluations. USAA offers exceptionally low premiums, more than 33% below the national average. American Family is also an excellent choice, with rates over 10% below the national average. For most people, American Family may be the best option due to USAA’s limited membership to military personnel and immediate family members.

When it comes to affordability, USAA takes the lead in offering the most affordable car insurance policies. On average, a USAA policy costs around $1,022 per year, which is $525 less than the national average annual rate. However, it’s important to note that USAA coverage is exclusively available to members of the military community. For those who don’t qualify for USAA, Geico often provides competitive rates, with an annual average rate of $1,250, which is $297 lower than the national average.

To find the best price on car insurance, it’s crucial to compare quotes from multiple insurers. Obtaining quotes from at least three insurance companies, while ensuring they offer the same type and amount of coverage, is recommended by the Insurance Information Institute (III). This allows you to accurately assess your options and choose a policy that suits your budget.

A car insurance premium is the specific amount of money you pay to your insurance company in exchange for coverage for you and your vehicle. You can typically choose to pay your premium either monthly or annually. Failing to pay your premium can lead to a lapse or cancellation of your car insurance coverage.

Car insurance can cover theft, but you need to add comprehensive coverage to your policy, in addition to basic liability and collision insurance. Comprehensive coverage ensures you’re protected if your car is stolen, vandalized, or damaged during a theft. However, it’s important to note that comprehensive coverage won’t cover personal items stolen from your vehicle. For such cases, you would need to rely on your homeowners or renters insurance.

In many cases, your car insurance policy will cover a rental car, especially if your policy includes collision, comprehensive, and liability coverage. However, keep in mind that there might be rental coverage limits. For instance, your insurance company may not cover the entire cost if you choose a high-end luxury rental or need a long-term rental. It’s essential to check with your car insurance company or agent to understand the specific rental coverage provided by your policy.

While insurance companies typically require you to insure a car that’s in your name, there are alternative options. You may consider obtaining a co-title with the car’s owner or having the owner transfer the title to your name. Another possibility is qualifying for a non-owner insurance policy if you don’t currently have a policy of your own. This type of insurance provides basic liability coverage for bodily injury and property damage when you’re driving someone else’s vehicle and are at fault for an accident. It can also cover you if you’ve lost your license and need to file an SR-22 form to reinstate it. Keep in mind that car insurance laws can vary from state to state, so research the requirements in your specific location.

A deductible in car insurance is the amount you agree to pay out of pocket before your insurance company covers the remaining costs of a claim. For example, if you have a $500 deductible and you file a claim for $2,000 in damages, you would pay the initial $500, and your insurance company would cover the remaining $1,500. Deductibles can vary depending on your policy and the type of coverage you have. Choosing a higher deductible can often lower your premium, but it means you’ll pay more if you need to make a claim.

4.9/5 - (21 votes)

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Get updates and learn from the best

3 responses to “Discover The Top 50 Car Insurance Companies That Everyone Is Talking About!​”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More To Explore

Do You Want To More?

drop us a line and keep in touch

List of Topics


Learn how we helped 100 top brands gain success.

Let's have a chat